We’ve all heard gay men teasing each other about being bottoms. In fact, I’m often told that my Mini Cooper is a “bottom-mobile.” While these jabs are often silly and lighthearted, I’ve speculated that this teasing arises from our own insecurities about bottoming – and, perhaps, our own masculinity or femininity issues.
This afternoon, while on the train back to Rhode Island from New York City, I read some research that might shed a little light on the situation.
First, the authors found that most gay men are attracted to masculinity.
To say that most gay men idolize masculinity isn’t politically correct. But when you spend any amount of time (and I have) perusing the adult content we consume, you’ll find plenty of evidence to support this theory. Think of how many cowboys, firemen, military men and football players you’ve seen in porn – and how the hair stylists, ballet dancers or makeup artists never seem to make the cut. And it goes beyond the stereotypically masculine professions; there are any number of “straight boy” websites (i.e., “Bait Bus”), that are geared towards a gay audience.
Of course, there’s still plenty of loving for flamboyant guys. As I’ve mentioned before, my friend Matt loves feminine men – and personally, I can see the attraction. But there’s no question that masculinity is a huge turn on for many gay men.
Second, the authors found that the majority of gay men are bottoms.
Whenever I visit a city, I often hear gay men say that it’s full of bottoms. In Boston, I’ve heard, “Boston is full of bottoms.” Turns out, they say the same thing about New York, San Francisco and just about everywhere else I’ve been. Maybe it doesn’t have to do with geography; maybe gay men just like getting banged.
According to analysis of gay dating sites, about 65% of gay men were looking to bottom. The remaining 35% were tops. The data does’t lie. And so I think it’s very interesting that though so many of us worship masculinity, we prefer the traditionally more female role of being penetrated and submitting.
I can’t help but think that idolizing masculinity and preferring to bottom puts a fairly large pool of gay men in a rather strange predicament. If you’re put off by femininity in others, it’s logical to speculate that you may dislike it in yourself. Perhaps, as gay men, we hate how much we love to bottom.


December 13, 2011 at 11:33 am
… i’m just lazy…
December 13, 2011 at 2:26 pm
@Anonoymous:
??????????!!?!,Anonymous:What do you mean?Lazy about what?_Most people are lazy about something,but your comment seems to be attached to nothing__Not your penis,I hope!!
December 13, 2011 at 8:23 pm
… im too lazy to top, i just like lying there
December 14, 2011 at 1:46 am
@Anonymous:
Anonymous:oh.
December 16, 2011 at 11:01 am
I love this comment. Agreed
December 16, 2011 at 11:33 am
who are you agreeing with?
December 15, 2011 at 9:03 pm
First of all….all marines are bottoms, or so I’ve heard! I think that clears up the stereotypical top/bottom thing. I guess I need to start my own blog. I have never understood the top/bottom thing. Most of the guys I knew growing up were completely versatile. I am completely versatile and have always been! Why would any gay man only want to enjoy half of his sexuality and or its experiential joy?!?! I’ve often thought there must be something missing in a man who is only or mostly only one or the other. I also don’t trust the data here. I don’t think of myself as being dominated when I bottom but, rather experiencing the joy that comes from another guy giving me that part of himself during that time. When I top its wonderful as well. I know the guy I’m with is enjoying what he’s getting and I’m enjoying him as well. It’s all great. I never compare myself to a woman. I am nothing like a woman nor will ever be. Most say I’m neither overly masculine or feminine. I’ve met a few guys who say they don’t like to bottom because they don’t like the feeling they get when the guy on top acts like a jack-rabbit. I tell them they are bottoming for the wrong guy! One guy finally found a top who knew what he was doing and now he knows what I’m talking about. I wish gay men would develop a healthier sexualtiy and disown the masculine/feminine label. I am a man who loves men. “Gay”
December 16, 2011 at 1:51 pm
Too F-ing many anonymouses/Anonymouses,a nonny-whatevers !!Please come up with other tags,
preferably not containing any variant of anonymous closer than hippopotamus. Mille Grazie.
December 19, 2011 at 1:50 pm
Any chance we can get a citation to the study you reference? I’d like to read it.
January 17, 2012 at 6:40 pm
@Greg:
Greg,re:Vale of Humility:
Just got your comment this afternoon[1/17/'12,5pm]…..Seems like months since I made mine.Did you know it was NC Governor Vance[a hall at Chapel Hill bears his name] who said it?The mountains of conceit,of course,war/are Virginia and South Carolina,specifically Charleston & the Low Country.
Always nice to write to a Tarheel[though I’m originally from both mountains.
Best,
bill(Guillermo3)
January 17, 2012 at 8:58 pm
bill(Guillermo3) — I only made the comment today (1/17/12) and wondered if you would even see it since it was an older post I was commenting on. (Not the only comment I added to this set of comments, actually, but I see I’m not the only Greg here either….) Just recently found Davey’s web sites and am enjoying getting caught-up on his interesting commentaries.
Based on your knowing the rare term “vale of humility,” I figured you must be from N.C. That’s home for me, although I now live in (on) one of the “mountains of conceit” referred to in the phrase (and I absolutely understand the meaning
. I didn’t realize that Gov. Vance had originated the quote, so thanks for the good history lesson! There’s a statue of him, in fact, not far from where I live now.
A few days ago I saw that you noticed my comments to Davey’s blog about getting boners in the shower at the gym. The story I shared about a hunky/sexy college friend I used to swim with–fyi, that took place in Woollen Gym.
Regards to you,
Greg
January 18, 2012 at 2:32 am
@Greg:
Great to hear from you,Greg !! Which of the mountains of conceit do you live on? SC,I hope_broke my heart when at age 16,we had to leave Charleston to go to Richmond.
BTW:I got my MFA at Chapel Hill.Ironically,my studio was across from the Math building.A friend & former colleague of mine in Philly was a math undergrad at the time.He told me that seeing my paintings persuaded him to go to art school in Philly.
Best,
bill(Guillermo3)
January 20, 2012 at 12:49 am
bill(Guillermo3) —
Glad you got my message! Alas, I am on the Va. “mountain” now, at the northern end. Charleston is such a lovely city (I’ve been there once)–but then, I think of Richmond as historically impressive too. I can appreciate, however, that at 16 it was probably a difficult move for you to make. Not sure where across from Phillips Hall your studio was, but perhaps it was near Ackland? I was a history major, but spent a lot of time in Hill Hall making music! If your work convinced a friend to study art, then you must be pretty good. I love art too, and have it all over my house….
Yours,
Greg
January 19, 2012 at 10:21 pm
I once read in an add “LA is like a bad tupperware party. Too many bottoms and no tops”. That sounds corny, but seems true. It’s hard to find someone who is 100% top. Most seem to follow stereotypes. Young gymnasts tend to attract tops. Biker, daddy types tend to attract bottoms, etc.
January 20, 2012 at 3:35 am
@Greg:
Wow,Greg !!!
Amazed & delighted to hear from you!….I just got home [ just after 2am,Friday],and ‘net addict that I am,had to check e-mail before eating/bed,etc: Went to sleep during the last of”Tinker,Tailor,Soldier,Spy”(my second viewing__great film,if you haven’t seen it),had to be awakened by a maintenance guy,and after hitting the streets to catch the subway ran into a huge group of partiers,all dressed in black,and mostly very drunk.Then a little late night grocery shopping & gathering kindling from a trees that fell a few blocks away.
Anyway,enough trivia___Living in N.VA?!:You have my deepest sympathies,though Arlington’s not too bad.I don’t think it was the quality of my painting that persuaded my friend to switch to art,but just a boost to help him do something he already really wanted[wish that had happened to me as far as knowing/accepting my being gay!!].If you’d like I’d love to keep up correspondence,so I’m leaving my e-mail address(a risk,because doing so before led to a plague of fake bill(Guillermo3)s posting exchange with a total whack job,but there are 3 very good correspondences with others.):billhooper4484@yahoo.com .
April 19, 2012 at 8:00 am
“nts-are-upward-118/ Thanks for that awesome posting. It saved MUCH time